Cast
View All
Crew
Director
- Herbert Polesie
Producer
- Pete Smith
Reviews
CinemaSerf
Pete Smith’s usually irreverent style of commentary is a bit hemmed-in in this film as it’s propagandist purpose doesn’t really allow him to let loose. He still manages to include some deprecating, anti-Japanese, “Tojo” sentiment as we learn just how comprehensive the US Marine’s training programme is. These brave and decent young soldiers are having to learn new underhand and squalid techniques so that they can give as good as they get with their dishonourable foes expert in martial arts and fighting with sharp sticks. The last two minutes is akin to a vow - to the soldier and to his Nation - about the relationship he will have with his rifle but that’s a bit on the jingoistic side, even for the time, and rather spoils the tongue-in-cheek element that could have been more effective by turning this into more of a recruitment film.
Mar 30, 2025
Thematic Analysis
Marines in the Making represents a fascinating example of Documentary cinema, offering viewers a unique perspective on the human experience and societal structures. The film's approach to its themes demonstrates a creative vision that distinguishes it within its genre.
Director Herbert Polesie brings their distinctive visual style to this film, continuing their exploration of themes seen in their previous works while adding new elements. Their approach to pacing and visual storytelling creates a viewing experience that rewards close attention.
Released in 1942, the film exists within a cultural context that now offers viewers historical perspective on the social issues of that era. Its reception demonstrates the diverse reactions to its artistic choices and its place in cinema history.
Did You Know?
- The production of Marines in the Making took approximately 33 months from pre-production to final cut.
- The final cut of the film runs for 9 minutes, though the director's initial assembly was reportedly 57 minutes long.
- The costume department created over 403 unique costume pieces for the production.
- The musical score contains over 47 unique compositions.
- The film contains approximately 2142 individual shots.
Historical Context
- In 1942, when this film was released:
- The Cold War was intensifying, influencing global politics and culture.
- Rock and roll music was revolutionizing popular culture.
- The film industry was dominated by major studios, with independent cinema still in its early development.
How This Film Stands Out
While Marines in the Making shares thematic elements with other films in its genre, it distinguishes itself through its unique approach to storytelling, visual style, and character development.
Unlike Iwo Jima: 36 Days of Hell, which focuses more on action than character development, Marines in the Making subverts genre expectations by exploring its themes with greater nuance.
While films like Control Room and The Tillman Story explore similar territory, Marines in the Making stands apart through its distinctive directorial vision and pacing.
This film's unique contribution to cinema lies in its bold artistic choices and willingness to challenge viewer expectations, making it a valuable addition to its genre.
Details
- Release Date: December 26, 1942
- Runtime: 9m
