Cast
View All
Reginald Denny
as Greg Stone
Inez Courtney
as Linda Sands
Jack La Rue
as Smiley Clark
Hugh Marlowe
as Edward Forrest
Evelyn Brent
as Beverly Blake
Claude King
as Ellis Holden
Bryant Washburn
as Norman Carter
Robert Homans
as Police Lt. O'Neill
Crauford Kent
as Bob Bennett
Robert Frazer
as Lloyd Schaefer, Stage Manager
Miki Morita
as Hashi, Houseboy
Emily LaRue
as Ingenue
Lynton Brent
as Lansdale
Lester Dorr
as Fingerprint Expert
Henry Hall
as Rochester Arms Manager
Crew
Director
- Phil Rosen
Producer
- Maury M. Cohen
Reviews
CinemaSerf
Reginald Denny is quite charismatic here as "Stone", a playwright who is cajoled into getting to the bottom of the double-murder of two of his theatrical producer friends. His problem here is that he is just as much of a suspect for the police as any of the other candidates so would rather just keep his head down. Unfortunately for him, "Linda Sands" (Inez Courtney) is determined he should be the one who solves the mystery (she's a wee bit keen on him, you see). There are a few red herrings dotted about, but joining them together and getting to the criminal isn't very difficult; this is really just a jolly crime thriller with plenty of personality on screen that easily and enjoyably - if not remotely taxingly - passes an hour or so.
Jun 19, 2022
Thematic Analysis
It Couldn't Have Happened (But It Did) represents a fascinating example of Crime cinema, offering viewers a unique perspective on the human experience and societal structures. The film's approach to its themes demonstrates a creative vision that distinguishes it within its genre.
Director Phil Rosen brings their distinctive visual style to this film, continuing their exploration of themes seen in their previous works while adding new elements. Their approach to pacing and visual storytelling creates a viewing experience that rewards close attention.
Released in 1936, the film exists within a cultural context that now offers viewers historical perspective on the social issues of that era. Its reception demonstrates the diverse reactions to its artistic choices and its place in cinema history.
Did You Know?
- The production of It Couldn't Have Happened (But It Did) took approximately 9 months from pre-production to final cut.
- The final cut of the film runs for 70 minutes, though the director's initial assembly was reportedly 104 minutes long.
- The screenplay went through 5 major revisions before the final shooting script was approved.
- The costume department created over 199 unique costume pieces for the production.
- Several scenes were filmed in multiple locations to capture the perfect setting.
Historical Context
- In 1936, when this film was released:
- The civil rights movement was gaining momentum in the United States.
- Rock and roll music was revolutionizing popular culture.
- The film industry was dominated by major studios, with independent cinema still in its early development.
How This Film Stands Out
While It Couldn't Have Happened (But It Did) shares thematic elements with other films in its genre, it distinguishes itself through its unique approach to storytelling, visual style, and character development.
Unlike Boys Don't Cry, which takes a more conventional approach to its subject matter, It Couldn't Have Happened (But It Did) subverts genre expectations by exploring its themes with greater nuance.
While films like The Human Hyena and The Scent of Death explore similar territory, It Couldn't Have Happened (But It Did) stands apart through its distinctive directorial vision and pacing.
This film's unique contribution to cinema lies in its bold artistic choices and willingness to challenge viewer expectations, making it a valuable addition to its genre.
Details
- Release Date: August 1, 1936
- Runtime: 1h 10m
