Cast
View AllGaladriel Stineman
as Cheryl Cooper
Denise Gossett
as Naomi Miller
Kevin Joy
as Levi Miller
Riley Beeson
as Esther Miller
J. Barrett Cooper
as Terrence Cox
Micah Lynn Hanson
as Hannah
Tatiana Harman
as Rachel Swartz
Candace Kirkpatrick
as Aunt Mitzi
Joe Kurak
as Samuel Swartz
Paul Anthony McLean
as Ben / Reuben
Lance E. Nichols
as Chief Twitchell
Ryan O'Quinn
as Seth Miller
Crew
Director
- Sandra L. Martin
Writer
- D.F.W. Buckingham
Reviews
Thematic Analysis
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise represents a fascinating example of Mystery cinema, offering viewers a unique perspective on interpersonal relationships and emotional connections. The film's approach to its themes demonstrates a creative vision that distinguishes it within its genre.
Director Sandra L. Martin brings their distinctive visual style to this film, continuing their exploration of themes seen in their previous works while adding new elements. Their approach to pacing and visual storytelling creates a viewing experience that rewards close attention.
Released in 2025, the film exists within a cultural context that continues to evolve with our understanding of its themes. Its reception demonstrates the diverse reactions to its artistic choices and its place in cinema history.
Did You Know?
- The production of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise took approximately 20 months from pre-production to final cut.
- With a budget of $0.6 million, the film represented a significant investment in bringing this story to the screen.
- The final cut of the film runs for 90 minutes, though the director's initial assembly was reportedly 119 minutes long.
- Some visual effects sequences took up to 12 months to complete.
- Several scenes were filmed in multiple locations to capture the perfect setting.
- The musical score contains over 79 unique compositions.
Historical Context
- In 2025, when this film is released:
- Streaming platforms had largely replaced traditional cinema and television models.
- Artificial intelligence was becoming increasingly integrated into daily life and creative industries.
- Streaming platforms were disrupting traditional distribution models and changing how audiences consumed films.
How This Film Stands Out
Details
- Release Date: April 20, 2025
- Runtime: 1h 30m
- Budget: $600,000
Where to Watch

