Skip to main content
Toby vs. Jeff: Creepypasta fan film Poster

Toby vs. Jeff: Creepypasta fan film (2021)

Jan 12, 2021 Action, Comedy, Crime 0h 40m
User Score
70%
1 votes

Two iconic characters of Creepypasta lore battle it out in this sequel to 2018's "Ticci Toby".

Overview

Produced by Freddy Leprechaun Productions, it is a movie featuring Creepypasta characters Ticci Toby (Tiernan Lachmann) and Jeff the Killer (Zac Cisco) created by Katoway and Sesseur which is a sequel to their other fan film "Ticci Toby" where Jeff the Killer helps bring Ticci Toby back to life and they end up in a gory battle as revenge for Jeff killing Toby's dear companion.

Tiernan Lachmann
Director

Top Billed Cast

Carolyn Myers
Carolyn Myers

Toby fan girl (voice)
Zac Cisco
Zac Cisco

Jeffry Woods
Tiernan Lachmann
Tiernan Lachmann

Toby Rogers
Ella Hamblin
Ella Hamblin

Girl
Derek Mason
Derek Mason

Girl's father
Tracey Richmond
Tracey Richmond

Tina Rucket
Liz Wolf
Liz Wolf

Camper #1 (Josh)
Zac Cisco
Zac Cisco

Camper #2 (Liu)
Tristan Osterberger
Tristan Osterberger

Victim watching TV

Full Cast & Crew

Media

Toby vs, Jeff: trailer
Toby vs, Jeff: trailer
Trailer
Toby vs. Jeff: teaser trailer 2
Toby vs. Jeff: teaser trailer 2
Trailer
Ticci Toby vs. Jeff the killer: teaser trailer
Ticci Toby vs. Jeff the killer: teaser trailer
Trailer
Loading Wikipedia summary...

Similar Movies

Nanny McPhee and the Big Bang
63%
Nanny McPhee and the Big Bang

Mar 26, 2010
Hue and Cry
64%
Hue and Cry

Feb 01, 1947
Heaven Knows What
65%
Heaven Knows What

May 29, 2015
Quando A Estrela Brilha...
100%
Quando A Estrela Brilha...

Dec 24, 2024
A Guardian's Heart
0%
A Guardian's Heart

May 15, 2026
French Girl
64%
French Girl

Mar 15, 2024
The Human Tornado
62%
The Human Tornado

Oct 02, 1976
Magical Mystery Tour
65%
Magical Mystery Tour

Dec 25, 1967
Party Girl
64%
Party Girl

Jun 09, 1995
Evasive Action
64%
Evasive Action

Jan 01, 1998
Boys Don't Cry
74%
Boys Don't Cry

Feb 25, 2000
Grown Ups
64%
Grown Ups

Jun 24, 2010

Reviews

Sign in to write a review.
A review by Monty Gravin
Written on April 25, 2025

PLOT
The opening character didn’t make sense to me at first but after learning she was labeled as “Toby fan girl,” it was clear that she was just such a big fan that she was willing to cut herself to bring Toby back to life. RECORD ME!
Very straightforward and not much room to be confused.
Most of the first half is spent by Jeff killin' and Toby ticking. Just kidding; He's just surviving in the woods and generally having a good time.
Though not very important, the cat parts were cute. Sadly, Jeff kills the cat to remind us he’s psychopathic. Trust me, I know. Rest in peace, Sophie. Luckily, Toby ended up revenging Sophie but died in the process. Rest in Toby.

PACE
A little slow when it comes to getting into the actual fight but the movie's only forty minutes long so it's no...

Read the full review on TMDb
×